Look up a ZIP
United States › Wisconsin › Vilas County › ZIP 54557

Home insurance & flood costs in ZIP 54557 (Presque Isle, WI)

Plain facts for homeowners in Presque Isle: what insurance cost here in recent years, how often claims were paid, and what flood coverage runs.

See the numbers

Historical averages, not a quote. Updated Oct 2026.

Illustration of a house on a hill in front of a large shield

ZIP 54557 at a glance

Four numbers most homeowners ask about first.

$1,415
Avg. home premium

Per policy in 2022 (inflation-adjusted), HO-3/HO-5 policies.

Too few
Avg. flood policy

Single-family NFIP policies that took effect in 2025.

0.64%
Nonrenewal rate

Share of policies not renewed by insurers in 2022. Typical U.S. ZIP: 0.81%.

3.4%
Claim frequency

Share of policies with a paid claim in 2022. Typical U.S. ZIP: 4.0%.

ZIP 54557 in numbers
$12,447
average paid claim (2022)
+1%
premium change 2018–2022, after inflation
0.36%
cancelled by insurers mid-term (2022)
1
single-family NFIP policies (2025)

What homeowners here pay

Each block pairs a short explanation with the data behind it.

Homeowners insurance

U.S. Treasury FIO, HO-3/HO-5 policies, 2018–2022

The average premium per policy in ZIP 54557 was $1,415 in 2022, 13% above the Vilas County typical ZIP ($1,249) and 9% below the typical U.S. ZIP code ($1,551). After adjusting for inflation, it held roughly steady between 2018 and 2022. About 3.4% of policies here had a paid claim in 2022, and insurers chose not to renew 0.64% of policies.

Vilas County overview

Average premium per policy

Inflation-adjusted dollars, Treasury FIO
ZIP 54557VilasU.S. typical ZIP

Flood insurance

FEMA NFIP single-family policies, 2022–2025

Only 1 single-family NFIP policy took effect in ZIP 54557 in 2025, too few for a meaningful average. The Vilas County average was $1,053.

Flood insurance data

Too few NFIP policies here to show reliable averages. FEMA's Flood Map Service Center shows the flood zone for any address.

Claims & hazards

Treasury FIO claim frequency; FEMA National Risk Index for Vilas County

The chart shows the share of homeowners policies in ZIP 54557 with at least one paid claim each year. FEMA rates hazards for the whole county, not single ZIP codes. The top hazards for Vilas County are listed below the chart, as national percentiles (100 = highest).

All county hazards

Policies with a paid claim

Share of policies, by year

Top county hazards

  • Cold wave95 · Relatively High
  • Strong wind81 · Relatively Moderate
  • Winter weather78 · Relatively Moderate
  • Lightning66 · Relatively Moderate
  • Hail62 · Relatively Low

Other ZIP codes in Vilas County

Average premium per policy in 2022 (Treasury FIO).

54521 Eagle River · $1,23854538 Lac Du Flambeau · $1,35354558 Saint Germain · $1,07354568 Woodruff · $1,110

Practical next steps

Simple things homeowners in ZIP 54557 can do with this information.

Compare at renewal. Premiums vary widely by ZIP code, home and insurer. Use these averages as a reference point, not a price, and compare a few quotes at renewal.
Keep records. A roof certificate, receipts for upgrades and photos of your home's condition can help when you shop for coverage or file a claim.
Review your deductibles. Many policies have separate wind, hail or hurricane deductibles set as a percentage of your dwelling coverage. Knowing yours in dollars helps you budget.
Check your flood zone. Look up your address on FEMA's Flood Map Service Center (msc.fema.gov). Standard home policies don't cover flood damage, and flood insurance usually has a 30-day waiting period, so it's worth sorting out before storm season.

Historical averages, not a quote. Homeowners figures are inflation-adjusted averages from the U.S. Treasury Federal Insurance Office "Supporting Underlying Metrics" (2018–2022, published January 2025). They cover HO-3/HO-5 policies from participating private insurers and exclude state residual-market plans (such as FAIR plans and Citizens), surplus-lines and flood coverage. Treasury notes that individual ZIP codes can contain data anomalies. Your price depends on your home, coverage and insurer.

Sources: U.S. Treasury FIO; FEMA OpenFEMA NFIP Redacted Policies v3 (data as of Sep 8, 2026); FEMA National Risk Index (December 2025); U.S. Census Bureau ZCTA-to-county relationship file (2020) and county adjacency file; GeoNames place names. How we calculate these numbers.

This product uses the FEMA OpenFEMA API and National Risk Index data, but is not endorsed by FEMA. The Federal Government or FEMA cannot vouch for the data or analyses derived from these data after the data have been retrieved from the Agency's website(s). SafeHomeFacts is independent and not affiliated with the U.S. Treasury, FEMA or any insurer.